Jane Austen

Critical Analysis

Home | Austen's Biography | Chronology | Famous Quotes | Austen's Era | Work Analysis I | Work Analysis II | Criticism | Letters | Minor Works | Themes | Inspiration | Style | Literary Devices | Photo Gallery | Bibliography

How Others Perceived Austen

Overview
Austen, who published her novels anonymously, was not a writer famous in her time, nor did she wish to be. Yet, her talent was the first to forge, from the eighteenth century novel of external incident and internal sensibility, an art form that fully and faithfully presented a vision of real life in a particular segment of the real world.

Her novels communicate a profound sense of the movement in English history--when the old Georgian world of the eighteenth century was being carried uneasily and reluctantly into the new world of Regency England, the Augustan world into the romantic.
__________________________________

Stepping Away from Tradition
Historically, the novels are a challenge to the idea of society as a civilizing force and to the image of man's fulfillment as an enlightened social being. They question the driving optimism of the period--that this, in the development of English society, was triumphantly the Age of Improvement. Improvement was the leading spirit of Regency England, its self-awarded palm. Certainly it was unequaled as a period of economic improvement, in the wake of the industrial revolution. The wartime economy accelerated this new prosperity. Alongside this material improvement there was an air of self-conscious, self-congratulatory improvement in manners, in religious zeal, in morality, in the popularization of science, philosophy, and the arts. It was the age of encyclopedias, displaying the scope and categories of human knowledge in digestible form. Books and essays paraded "Improvement" in their titles.
_____________________________________


Writing From Experience
Ironically, one of Jane Austen's major achievements in the novels is to have captured the total illusion of the gentry's vision, the experience of living in privileged isolation, of being party to a privileged outlook, of belonging to a privileged community, whose distresses, such as they are, are private, mild, and genteel. Each of the homes and neighborhoods is its own "little social commonwealth," a microcosm, the center of a minute universe. The irony is implicit. The miniature issues of these little worlds, so realistic, so much the center of the stage, vivid and magnified to the point of surrealism, imply another, larger world beyond: "the flourishing grandeur of a Country, is but another term for the depression and misery of the people . . . to speak of the expensive luxury and refinements of an age, is but, with cruel irony, to remind us how many myriads are destitute." John Thelwall, in The Peripatetic (1793), was presenting a line of argument which was familiar to Jane Austen's audience and which the novels artfully exploit. "The depression and misery" of the common people was a theme she could never handle directly; her way was to treat it by silent implication . . .

Reaction to Her Writings
W.H. Auden's verse epistle "Letter to Lord Byron" confesses a discomfort at finding such a streak of cold realism in the nature of Austen's works:

You could not shock her more than she shocks me:
Beside her Joyce seems innocent as grass.
It makes me most uncomfortable to see
An English spinster of the middle class
Describe the amorous effects of "brass",
Reveal so frankly and with such sobriety
The economic basis of society.

____________________________________

Modern Critics
Modern critics have asserted that Austen's interest in heredity, education, economics, and social forces leaves no doubt that her fictional world is a modern one unconcerned with religious affairs. But some critics insist that the moral intensity of the novels strongly indicate a spiritual dimension to the stories. Critics see this dimension in the willingness of moderate and practical heroines to sacrifice their chances of worldly happiness rather than compromise their basic values, the constant emphasis on unselfish love and self-sacrifice, and the awareness of the limitations and mystery of the human mind and personality.

More on www.pemberley.com